I'm too much of a partisan to be able to look at these things objectively.
I thought both did very well and suspect Obama supporters will feel he won while McCain supporters felt McCain won.
Is it just me or does it appear that McCain really dislikes Obama? He seemed to scold him on several occasions.
Obama is so cool under pressure it's almost unnerving.
I do think Obama missed a chance to zing McCain by asking him directly where was the judgment he is so proud of when Pres Bush choose to invade Iraq with McCain being his biggest cheerleader.